Through the Eyes of a Conservator

A Day's Work - the Giornata Map with Arrows Showing Day to Day Work Progression over Shape Layer. 1/16 Resolution

IIIF Drag-n-drop

Diego Rivera, The Marriage of the Artistic Expression of the North and of the South on This Continent, also known as Pan American Unity, 1940, 6.7 meters tall by 22.47 meters wide (22 X 74 feet); courtesy City College of San Francisco; © 2020 Banco de México Diego Rivera and Frida Kahlo Museums Trust, Mexico City / Artists Rights Society (ARS), New York; Color and Shape Images - © Cultural Heritage Imaging; Giornata and Condition Maps - Courtesy of SFMOMA with special thanks to Site & Studio Conservation.


In addition to the mural’s shape and color, this exhibit of Pan American Unity includes conservation information developed by a special SFMOMA conservation team in 2019.


A Day's Work -- The Giornata Map

This layer shows the area of the fresco Diego Rivera painted each day - also called a giornata. The term "giornata" comes from the Italian word for "day": "giorno".

Rivera carefully planned the area of the fresco he would paint each day because the pigments must be painted on the plaster before the plaster "sets" for the pigment to permanently bond to the plaster. The setting of the plaster limited the area of plaster he could paint. Rivera carefully concealed the boundaries between the giornata by weaving them between major compositional elements, often following the outlines of people, buildings, and machines. Assistants applied the thin wet plaster layer. These graphics are registered to the underlying shape and color layers and can be displayed and inspected as desired by the viewer.

The Giornata Color Key shows the boundary of each day’s work area as a black line. It also uses an orange line to indicate areas of pentimento.

Left: The orange line denotes Pentimento area in this detail from Panel 4. Right: DEM (Shape) of the same area. Image: Cultural Heritage Imaging. Giornata map courtesy of SFMOMA with special thanks to Site & Studio Conservation.

Pentimento

Areas indicated by an orange line represent “pentimento.” Pentimento or “repentance” in Italian indicates a change made by the artist during the creation of the work. On Pan American Unity these areas are easy to find because Rivera added a new plaster layer over the top of the original. These elevated areas are easily distinguished in the Digital Elevation Model (DEM) layer. In fact, examination of the DEM layer directly led the conservators to identify a new pentimento region on the fresco.

Day After Day –– the Work Progression (Arrows)

This layer shows how one day’s work followed another as the painting of the mural progressed. By examining the plaster joints between each day’s work area, it is possible for the conservators to see which work area was painted first and which followed later. The direction the arrows are pointing indicate the day’s work area that was completed later.

Top: Giornata map on the color layer over a detail from Panel 2. Bottom: the DEM (Shape) of the same area. Image: Cultural Heritage Imaging. Giornata map courtesy of SFMOMA with special thanks to Site & Studio Conservation.

Experiments to Extend the Duration of the Giornata

Wayne Lammers spraying a concoction of 50% Butanol, 50% Water, which retarded the drying time of the plaster to 18 hours. WPA Archive.

Diego Rivera used an experimental technique on the fresco in an attempt to delay the setting of the plaster and extend the time he had to paint. The technique, developed by Ely de Vescovi, used the chemical Butanol, applied with a spray gun directly on the plaster. It was believed that a 50% Butanol 50% water solution could retard the setting of the plaster for up to 18 hours. It is clear from the surface relief of the DEM layer that, while there are many areas where Rivera painted into the plaster when it was soft and malleable, there are areas that show no imprint from the paintbrush at all. This suggests that the plaster setting was well-advanced at the time of painting.

The effect of the technique on the adherence of the pigment to the plaster surface is under investigation.

Condition Map Layer

Condition Map on Grayscale Over Color and Shape Layers. 1/16 Resolution

IIIF Drag-n-drop

Diego Rivera, The Marriage of the Artistic Expression of the North and of the South on This Continent, also known as Pan American Unity, 1940, 6.7 meters tall by 22.47 meters wide (22 X 74 feet); courtesy City College of San Francisco; © 2020 Banco de México Diego Rivera and Frida Kahlo Museums Trust, Mexico City / Artists Rights Society (ARS), New York; Color and Shape Images - © Cultural Heritage Imaging; Giornata and Condition Maps - Courtesy of SFMOMA with special thanks to Site & Studio Conservation.

The special conservation team, sponsored by SFMOMA, provided a condition information map showing issues present in the mural. This layer contains multi-colored graphics with each color indicating a different condition type. The team worked to simplify and prioritize all of the conservation data into a meaningful presentation for the general public. In consultation with CHI, the conservation team decided to show 4 types of condition information: powdering, cracks, flaking, and delamination. Different levels identified to show the degree of powdering and flaking were collapsed into a single representation for each category to simplify the presentation of condition issues.

Detail from Panel 1. Left: condition information on the Color layer. Right: DEM (Shape) of the same area. Image: Cultural Heritage Imaging. Condition Map Courtesy of SFMOMA with special thanks to Site & Studio Conservation